Ivermectin and Covid-19: An Inconvenient Truth
5
Jul 2021

Lees meer in

A new study found those who used ivermectin may have to be placed on mechanical life support earlier when they contract Covid-19. Dave reflects on this study.

From the onset of the Covid-19 pandemic I have cautioned against the use of unproven treatments for this terrifying disease. It is embedded in human nature, especially in times of crisis and uncertainty, to attempt home grown cures and remedies for ailments, and, as can be predicted, these treatments may work, or not. Interwoven in this dynamic, one may find placebo effects, which should not be discarded in medical terms. My maternal grandmother believed fervently, that crushed canna (Canna indica) leaves, used as a cold compress on the forehead, relieved headaches. Much to my long-suffering grandfather’s relief, this worked for her.

This brings me to the subject of Ivermectin as a cure or treatment for Covid-19. A scientific paper was published on Friday in a prestigious medical forum, BMC (British Medical Council) and here are the salient findings:

1 Background

Current evidence regarding the efficacy of ivermectin for the treatment of COVID-19 patients is still unclear, and the WHO recommends its use only for clinical studies. Therefore, the aim of this study is to evaluate the efficacy of ivermectin in preventing hospitalizations in patients with COVID-19 (IVERCORCOVID19).

2 Methods

A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study was conducted in the community between August 19, 2020 and February 22, 2021 in the province of Corrientes, Argentina.

3 Randomization

Randomization was performed by one of the investigators through the web-based system using randomly permuted blocks in a 1:1 ratio (Supplementary Appendix). The investigator who performed the randomization was not involved in the dispensing of the medication, inclusion, and follow-up of the patients. The rest of the investigators were blinded to the treatment received, as were the patients. Patients were consecutively assigned to the treatment kit in ascending order at inclusion.

4 Outcomes

The primary outcome was hospitalization for any reason of patients with COVID-19. This was defined as a stay of at least 24 hours in a health institution, in any of its services, at any point from randomization until the end of study visit.

5 Statistical methods

To calculate the sample size, it was assumed that 10% of the patients required hospitalization, applying a statistical significance level of 0.05 and with a statistical power of 80%. When the trial was designed, there was not enough evidence of the potential benefit of ivermectin in these patients, therefore calculations were based on an estimated odds ratio in the ivermectin arm between 0.3 and 0.5 with the aim of including a total of 500 patients (250 patients in each group).

6 The results

During the study period, 22,533 SARS-CoV2 positive cases were evaluated for eligibility, of which 501 patients were included. Two hundred and fifty patients were randomized to ivermectin and 251 to placebo. In the ivermectin group, 249 patients had 100% compliance and 1 had 50% compliance. In the placebo group, 248 patients had 100% compliance, 2 patients had 50% compliance and 1 patient had 0% compliance. Considering that an intention-to-treat analysis was performed, all 501 patients were included for the analysis of primary and secondary outcomes. There were no arm crossovers.

Of all the individuals who participated in the study, 35 (6.99%) required hospitalization at any point from randomization to their end of study visit. Of these, 14 (5.60%) belonged to the ivermectin group and 21 (8.37%) to the placebo group. There were no statistically significant differences between the two groups [odds ratio 0.65; 95%CI, 0.32–1.31; p = 0.227]

7 Important findings

  • As for mortality, there were no significant differences between the two groups.
  • In the IVERCORCOVID19 trial, in patients with a positive COVID-19 nasal swab by RT-PCR technique in the last 48 hours, ivermectin in a staggered dose according to the patient’s weight for 2 days had no significant effect on preventing hospitalization of patients with COVID-19
  • Patients who received ivermectin required invasive mechanical ventilatory support earlier.

I urge readers of this forum to read this study with care, and with attention. It is your democratic and constitutional right to apply any treatment as preventative, or as a cure for any ailment, since the world is awash with countless remedies and therapies for every known medical condition. It is, however, reckless to spread unfounded and possibly false information regarding public health, especially in dealing with a global pandemic.

The tangerine revisited

The tangerine revisited

This over familiar fruit, usually eaten fresh, can be transformed, with imagination, into a sublime dessert.

VRA VIR DAVE

How to get rid of cockroaches in an ecologically friendly way

Follow this advice if you want to get rid of cockroaches without any unnatural poisons.

Reader asks: Can you identify this awfully ugly bug?

This little bugger is not what it seems to be.

What!? Crab catches a . . . swallow?

A reader says they could not believe their eyes. But could this be true? Read on…

HERINNERINGE

A small tribute to my mother

Only through repeating small rituals, can we maintain our sense of self, and our sense of belonging.

Dave remembers the Tulbagh earthquake

The night of the earthquake, another story played itself out deadly on Robertson.

Remembrance of my grandmother

Dave remembers Grandma Lily, the navels of Robertson and the rites that must continue to exist.

VERKENNINGS

Ons gekneusde planeet

Ons kan enigiets met die aarde aanvang, ‘n globale kernoorlog, die algehele smelt van al die ys, besoedeling – maar lewe sal aanhou. Maar dit sal nie meer herkenbare lewe wees nie…

Video: The heaven is on Spookfontein

A weekend on the Spookfontein wine farm shows you again where heaven can be.

Avocados in a nutshell: What to keep in mind

It’s amazing how many queries I receive about problems with avocado trees. Here are some guidelines to deal with this tree successfully.